Monday, January 9, 2012

Will life insurance company honour the claim after your death?

In November 2010, Bachhat carried out a claim settlement analysis of life insurance companies to understand which company provides the assurance of quick settlement of claims.  The analysis carried out in November was based on the data for the year 2009-10.  Bachhat had stated to do more such analysis in future and today we shall have a look at how the life insurance companies have fared in their claim settlement for the year 2010-11.

Why claim settlement analysis is important?

Before deep diving into the analysis, let us recap why the analysis of claim settlement is important.  Besides the premium charged by the insurer, two additional important things one should consider before choosing an insurer is the probability of getting the claim settled in the event of the death and the time taken to settle the claim. 

Nobody will like to be in a situation where one has paid the premium diligently for 20 years and after his death, the claim is disapproved for any reason.  One will also not like to be in a situation where his family gets the insurance proceeds after 6 months or say even after 1 year of the death.  Hence it is necessary to do the analysis of claims settled by the insurance companies.  It will help you know which company rejects the least number of claims and process the claims quicker.

Claim Settlement Analysis

The table below gives the best five and the bottom five life insurance companies in terms of claim rejection for the year 2010-11.  Best companies have the least claim rejection ratio whereas bottom five companies have the highest claim rejection ratio. The list is further broken down into how old these rejected policies where when the death occurred.  Older the policies less should be the chance of rejection. 

Best five insurance companies in terms of claim rejection
Insurer
% Claims Rejected
< 2 yrs old policy
> 2 yrs old policy
LIC
1%
92%
8%
Star Union Dai-ichi
1%
100%
0%
ICICI Prudential
3%
82%
18%
ING Vyasa
4%
88%
12%
Kotak
4%
92%
8%

Bottom five insurance companies in terms of claim rejection
Insurer
% Claims Rejected
< 2 yrs old policy
> 2 yrs old policy
Aegon Religare
45%
100%
0%
Shriram Life
26%
88%
12%
Future Generali
22%
100%
0%
IDBI Federal
21%
94%
6%
DLF Pramerica
20%
100%
0%

LIC is the best amongst the entire lot of insurance companies with only 1% of the claims getting rejected.  ICICI Prudential and Kotak Life are amongst the private insurance companies making it to the best five listing.

Aegon Religare tops the list of bottom five companies with 45 out of every 100 claims rejected during the period under review.  Shriram Life, Future Generali Life, IDBI Federal and DLF Pramerica are other insurance companies which have claim rejection ratio of greater than 20%.

If we notice the age of the policies for which claims are rejected, mostly all of them are less than 2 years old.  In Aegon Religare case, all the claims rejected are for policies less than 2 years old.  The relevance of 2 years is insurance company can not reject claims for policies which are more than 2 years old on the basis that the policy was taken based on misrepresented facts, unless the insurance company shows that such misrepresentation was material and fraudulently made and policy holder knew that he is misrepresenting material fact.  Thus, generally unless proved otherwise by the insurance company, claim pertaining to policies more than two years old should get settled.  However, that does not mean that any claims made within first 2 years of the policy should be rejected.  Such claims can go for additional scrutiny but should get settled if found in order.

Thus it becomes interesting to know the companies which have rejected most numbers of claims for policies greater than 2 years.

Insurer
% Claims Rejected
< 2 yrs old policy
> 2 yrs old policy
SBI
17%
58%
42%
Aviva
12%
72%
28%
ICICI Prudential
3%
82%
18%
Bajaj Allianz
7%
83%
17%
ING Vyasa
4%
88%
12%

For eg. SBI Life has rejected 17 out of every 100 claims made.  42% of such rejected claims are for policies in force for more than 2 years.  There has to be very compelling reasons to reject such claims and it shall be interesting to know about such reasons. 

It shall also be interesting to know how many of the claims made within first 2 years of the policy are settled.  Unfortunately, the insurance companies are not mandated to provide such details.

Another way to look at the claim rejection ratio is to check whether such high rejection ratios are one time event or a regular feature.  The graph below provides claim rejection ratio for all life insurance companies for last two years and one can notice that there has not been substantial difference in the two years.  Furthermore, many of the companies have rejected more claims in 2010-11 as compared to in 2009-10.

Claim Turnaround Time 

Let us now look at the time taken for insurance companies to settle the claim once they receive claim intimation from the claimant.  There can be some delays due to additional documents required by the insurance companies or on account of certain queries raised on the policies.  However, generally the claim settlement should not be prolonged.
 
There are insurance companies where more than 50% of the claims submitted are outstanding for more than 3 months.  The graph below provides an overview, with the quickest turnaround companies at the top and the slowest at the bottom.  The colours in each bar represent the time taken to settle the claims.

Sahara has the worst turnaround time followed by Future Generali Life and Shriram Life.  The better way to look at this could be to see the response time once all the documents relating to claim are submitted by the claimant.  Bachhat is compiling list of such instances and shall do a follow up post on the same.

Conclusion 

LIC stands out with the lowest claim rejection ratio and also a decent turnaround time.  In private sector, Kotak Life and ICICI Prudential have low claim rejection ratio.  Kotak Life is better than ICICI Prudential in rejecting claims for policies in force for more than 2 years, whereas ICICI Prudential scores over Kotak Life in claim turnaround time.  Companies like Aegon Religare and Star Union Daichi have started operations in last 2-4 years and we need to give them more time so that more sensible analysis can be carried out on their claim settlement details.

Thus the cheapest term plan available may not be the best one to opt for.  One has to also look at the company’s claim settlement ratio as well as claim turnaround time before zeroing on any insurance company.

Have any of yours insurance claim got rejected? I shall be happy to hear your experiences, views and suggestions in the comment section below.

Post revised on January 12, 2012

Data source for analysis: IRDA Annual Report 2010-11 and Insurance companies website

5 comments:

  1. Hi Vishal.
    What definitions were used by you to arrive at the turn around time for each insurer to settle claims?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Manallii,

      Each insurance company provides details of time taken by them to settle the claims once all the documents are received from the claimant.

      Claim turnaround time is calculated on that basis.

      For eg: If an insurance company settles 100 claims in a year and 30 out of them takes more than 3 months, 30% of the claims took more than 3 months to get settled and is reflected accordingly in the graph provided above.

      However, it seems that there has been inconsistency in the companies reporting the data. Few of them have reported it from the date the first claim intimation was received and others have reported from the date of receipt of all documents.

      The post has been revised accordingly. Thanks.

      Delete
  2. It's very simple to find out any matter on net as compared to textbooks, as I found this piece of writing at this web site.
    Also visit my homepage ; feu de cheminée

    ReplyDelete
  3. No . Everyone's pounds fluctuates and it depends on the person on how much the weight fluctuates. Do not be concerned, as there is nothing incorrect. Best of luck!

    my website: natural weight loss pills for women

    ReplyDelete
  4. Is is true that some insurance policies are market based means the benefits of the policy will increase or decrease according to market performance of the insurance company?

    Thanks
    William Martin

    PPI Claims Made Simple

    ReplyDelete